GENRE: Documentary
DIRECTOR: Nathan Fielder & Lance Oppenheim
You Can See Everything was met with enthusiastic reactions and I must confess I went watching it very hyped... and it met all the expectations and it proved itself as a poignant piece of filmmaking that's both engaging and genre defying rather than documentary genre-defining. It's a disruptor movie!
This film has a very simple premise: filming Elizabeth Holmes and her husband and kids' everyday life before she goes to jail. At first you might think you are watching a mix between a reality show and the behind the scenes of that reality where you see one of the directors expressing his frustrations and making his own analysis about what he has been seeing. It's when You Can See Everything starts integrating Hitchcockian elements that it starts feeling truly alive and way more than a documentary - it starts touching the feature film realm. By making a woman the subject of his attention and then the subject of his obsession to have her vanishing in the middle of the film to have her being somewhat replaced by another woman playing her, Fielder and Oppenheim unveil this fascinating "documentary" with the same structure as Vertigo (1958). And that's why it is so engaging and intriguing: it becomes an investigation thriller.
This is in "reality" a quest for the Holy Grail: what's the truth? It's a documentary, a narrative feature film, a behind the scenes, as it blurs the line between reality and deceit, between being yourself and making a character for public projection, between truth and if the reality you believe is truthful...! What you assume as reality in the very beginning then it's presented under a brand new perspective by the end when the audience undertands that facts, perceptions, feelings and relationships are, in fact, connected and all these elements build a huge web around Holmes, her intentions, her persona and her crimes. The men behind the camera are even humble enough to admit how things changed since the production began. This documentary is, in fact, an anti-documentary as it assumes things take a swing according to the directors perspective of the subject and that swing might also change the audiences' mind. Might Holmes have manipulated the director in order that he presents her in a way that audiences might empathize with her (as a loving mother and a perfect wife who'd build monuments of love for her husband)? Is it possible to be completely objective when making a documentary since it's a product of the human mind and this same human mind is not objective and it's affected by emotions and feelings? You can see everything, but is she showing everything? Or is she manipulating the way you see her like a cynical mastermind psychopath? You Can See Everything is truly intriguing to say the less as it feels more as a parable than a documentary (and an anti-AI movie by the way).
There's a couple of times I felt it to be a bit too long but it presents a strong plot twist right when things seem to cool off. Fielder & Oppenheim are genius who made a work that's truly defies cinematic genre definition. As for Amanda Seyfried (previously mentioned everywhere as REDACTED) also challenges your concept of film acting - who are you when you are yourself, when you are the character and who are you when you have a camera point at you? (Intriguing in the same level as Scarlett Johansson's voice only acting in Her). What kind of movie is this? Is Seyfried actually acting? Is Holmes acting? Who is Elizabeth Holmes? So many questions to keep you completely absorved trying to crack the enigma here.
Technically, it features impecable and dynamic editing and an unpretentious-looking cinematography work that balances lights, shadows, interesting mise-en-scène and a lot of unconfortable close-ups that seem to absorb the soul of the people on-screen. Great soud mixing as well.
So, while the almost 3h of runtime might scare you like it did to me, I must say I was mostly engaged (as a human being). You Can See Everything might not offer objective answers and it might have never been its purpose - it blends many elements that defy your conception of documentary and it never presents its content as being true. It's a human chess game that reaches the "check" but never the checkmate, yet this frustration is the key for it feeling as a daring cinematic experience. I did say everything, but I still know nothing... only my own personal perception and opinion on the matter.
RATING: 9/10
Oscar potential categories:
- Best Picture
- Best Director
- Best Documentary
- Best Editing
- Best Cinematography
- Best Sound


Comments