Skip to main content

REVIEW: "Ghost in the Shell"

Genre: Action & Adventure, Drama, Science-Fiction
Directed by: Rupert Sanders
Written by: Jonathan Herman, Jamie Moss
Starring: Scarlett Johansson, Pilou Asbæk, Michael Pitt, Takeshi Kitano and Juliette Binoche
In Theaters: Mar 31, 2017 (Wide)
Runtime: 106 minutes
Since the day it was announced Scarlett Johansson was cast as Motoko Kusanagi in a live-action adaptation of Ghost in the Shell (called by simply The Major or "Mira" in the movie), there were a lot of controversy around the whitewashing of an iconic manga character. But, guess what: it is Johansson's ghost who saves the movie from being a huge misfire.
The source material from the 1996's animated film of the same name is unique, with a sublime soul, hard philosophic questions and some amazing visuals. That said I must confess I was surprised by the choice of Rupert Sanders for the director's chair, since he showed so little as a storyteller in Snow White and the Huntsman and being able to tell a story and ask the audiences to think was something essential for a Ghost in the Shell adaptation. Well, the director might fail as a storyteller, but I must recognize it would be difficult to elevate such a weak screenplay. No matter what, Sanders amazes the audiences with the world he built on-screen: everything's so amazing and every detail is so polished, turning Ghost in the Shell into one of the most beautiful movies to look at in recent years. Production design, cinematography work and visual effects all work like an A-class symphony in order to create a visual feast on-screen - kudos for the amazing recreation of the shelling sequence!
Just like I said, thank God they cast Scarlett Johansson in this one. While most of the critics who assumed to be fans of the original movie seem more concerned to keep the whitewashing controversy alive than to actually review the lead's performance, I must say I was quite impressed with Johansson once again. After a series of acting performances we can name "What means to be human?" composed by her turns in Her, Lucy and Under the Skin, I asked myself how could Johansson pull a different performance from a material that's similar to the previous ones... but she delivers one of the most refined performances in the last years of the sci-fi genre. She's a living weapon, for sure, but if you look at her eyes she shows she has a soul, an inner something that's far more complex and subjetive than the action sequences she's in. The script demands Johansson to ask the wrong questions, but in the quieter moments you understand she is haunted by her ghost. The actress proves she's a true star with this commanding performance, but I don't think it will be the acting turn that will give her the first Oscar nomination she's overdue for.
Thumbs up for Pilou Asbæk, who has great chemistry with the female lead and manages to make a huge impression everytime he's on-screen. The sound work is spectacular and some of the action scenes are thrilling too... Too bad it fails to capture the essence of its source material - a beautiful and visually magnetic shell but a ghost that only lives in Scarlett Johansson and not in the movie has a whole.

RATING: 3 / 5

Academy Award playing categories:
  • Best Cinematography
  • Best Production Design
  • Best Sound Editing
  • Best Sound Mixing
  • Best Visual Effects


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

TOP 35 Actors and Actresses Under 35 Working Today - 2017

The almost annual TOP 35 Actors and Actresses Under 35 Working Today is out, with me considering the performers' performances of 2016 also. We have a few changes since last year's list, with Greta Gerwig toping the list thanks to her last 3 great performances in Mistress America , Maggie's Plan and the Oscar buzzy acting turn in 20th Century Women . Scarlett Johansson comes second with her latest distinguished performance being in 2014 ( Under the Skin ), but she managed to be at the spotligh this year thanks to her fine turns in critically acclaimed movies: Hail, Caesar! , Captain America: Civil War , The Jungle Book (voice) and Sing (voice). Emily Blunt adds another great performance to her resume in The Girl on the Train and she comes third, while Elle Fanning 's turning into one of the finest actresses and she's getting to play more adult and complex parts like The Neon Demon  and 20th Century Women 's (her two best performances since Super 8 ). Finall

TOP 10 Most Promising Movie Actors (under 30)

Today I discussed about how awful some "teen icons" are and then we talked about some exceptions. So, I decided to make a little list, a TOP 10, with the male actors that I think that will become music in an ocean of noise somewhere in the future (I did one list before, but it was a little bit pathetic and I didn't justify my choices). Let's start... 1 - Ryan Gosling He may not have a huge list of movies in his body of work, but the few times he makes something, all the time he almost carries the movie. In fact, Gosling is a proof that talent does exist and that you don't need excentrical characters to receive raves. He rose to fame after the big screen adaptation of The Notebook (2004) and then received lots of critical praise for his performances in movies like Half Nelson (that gave him an Oscar, a SAG Award and other major awards nominations), Lars and the Real Girl (that gave him a Golden Globe, a SAG Award and other major awards nominations) and Fractur

TOP 35 Actors and Actresses with or under 35 years old: 2018

I think it was my TOP 35 under 35 list I've ever done since I remember: so many great performers emerged last year with distinguished performances that elevated their previous works (I'm talking about Elizabeth Olsen , Lucas Hedges , Robert Pattinson , Gaspard Ulliel , Tessa Thompson or Jamie Bell , for example). I'm kinda sad I felt "forced" at letting Jonah Hill ( Moneyball and The Wolf of Wall Street ) and Emma Watson ( The Perks of Being a Wallflower , The Bling Ring and 2017's Beauty and the Beast ) out of the list. Congratulations to Kirsten Dunst , who turned 35 last year so she can not be included in this year's list - such an amazing child actress turned movie star, who delivered memorable performances in Interview with the Vampire (1994), The Virgin Suicides (1999), The Cat's Meow (2002) or Melancholia (2011). This year, Saoirse Ronan tops the list thanks to two great performances: On Chesil Beach and an iconic acting turn in Lad